Washington Intermediate School geometry class, 1954 HSPLS
Native Response

Student Experiences

In stories from schools across the territory, Native students repeatedly emphasized the importance of obtaining a good education to ensure a secure future. They understood that success at school helped pave a path to white-collar employment as stenographers, social workers, clerks, secretaries, nurses, lawyers, doctors, and teachers. One Native student believed as much when he wrote, “Hawaiian-born children of my group are attending schools and educational institutions for the benefit of their lives.”[1]

Mixed in with their optimism, Native students consistently worried about the future of their people. Another student lamented that “everytime” she thought about her people, she felt a “pang of regret that these islands were ever discovered.” Her words captured the grim and poignant reality of Hawaiians, who never envisioned that “someday there [sic] lands would be taken from them,” or “shoved toward the ‘outside’ districts.”

Still, despite the gloom, like so many other Native students, this girl expressed hope for the future believing that, through public education, “Hawaiian children are now being taught how to help their people.”[2]

Kapaa High School metal shop class
Kapa‘a High School metal shop class, 1952 HSPLS
portrait of girls in front of US flag
Washington Intermediate School, 1954 HSPLS
McKinley High 1920
McKinley High citizenship class, 1920 HSPLS
baldwin high school library
Baldwin High School Library, 1944 HSPLS
children playing drums
Students playing drums Hawaii State Archives, Photograph Collection, PP-13-10-034
school children playing in playground
Hawaii State Archives, Photograph Collection, PP-13-10-037
Hawaiian schoolchildren
Hawaiian schoolchildren, 1900 Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons (attribution not legally required)

It is also important to remember no data source, of course, is perfect. These essays were not composed by students as personal memoirs to themselves but, instead, were responses to open-ended research questions solicited by teachers for William C. Smith, a visiting sociology professor from the University of Southern California conducting research on race relations in Hawaiʻi. Native students revealed a range of experiences and attitudes in their responses to Smith’s questions but how they replied may very well have been shaped to varying degrees by their perceptions of what their teachers expected to hear as well as the survey questions’ stress on race and cultural mixing. As a result, knowing the context of their assignment possibly, at times, pressured many Native students to project pro-American and/or pro-English-language positions. Nevertheless, several Native students openly asserted pride in their indigeneity, often self-identifying as “part Hawaiian.” Such expressions were unprompted by any specific question and thus not a focus of Smith’s survey. This understanding helps reinforce the serendipitous significance of those who plainly professed their cultural pride as evidence of an assertive Indigenous consciousness resisting Americanization.

HH69
Hilo High School, male
There is racial prejudice here (Hawai‘i) and not only towards the Japanese but part Hawaiians and pures.
HH40
Hilo High School, female
I'm a daughter of the soil.
N195
Normal School in Puʻunēnē, Maui, female
I feel that I must do something here for the Hawaiians.
MK122
McKinley High School, female
my family and friends...are always helping me to become successful. This has given me... courage to go through school
N190
Punahou School, female
I ask ‘Why?’ Are the Haoles privileged characters?
MK359
McKinley High School, female
The Hawaiian-born children of my racial group are trying hard to get a good education.
N197
I sincerely feel that it is important that I should know how to speak my own language
HH257
Hilo High School, female
I am a part-Hawaiian year old girl. I’m proud of it.

[1] WCSC R15 MK152, 1–2, William Carlson Smith papers, Reel 15, Life Histories of Students: Selected Series, University of Hawaiʻi-Mānoa Hamilton Library, Honolulu, Hawaiʻi.
Initials used represent the institutions Native students attended at the time of their life histories. H – University of Hawaiʻi-Mānoa, N – Normal School, MK – McKinley High School, HH – Hilo High School. WCSC – William Carlson Smith Collection, R – Reel.
[2] WCSC R4 HH60, 2,11.